Grading Standards
How we grade.
We check each card's centering, corners, edges, and surface to determine its overall condition. Every card is evaluated across all four areas — no single factor determines the grade on its own.
Four Areas of Evaluation
Centering
How evenly the card's design sits between its borders. Centering alone does not determine the grade — all four condition areas matter.
Corners
The sharpest corners signal minimal handling. Look for rounding, whitening, or wear at each point.
Edges
Clean, smooth edges reflect careful storage. Chipping, roughness, or visible damage along any edge affects the overall condition.
Surface
The face and back of the card. Scratches, print lines, dents, stains, or creases all factor into the surface assessment.
The Grade Scale
Gem Mint
An outstanding card with sharp corners, clean edges, and a clean surface. Only tiny factory imperfections that do not distract from its appearance are allowed.
Front 55/45 or better · Back 75/25 or better
Mint
A card in excellent condition with one small flaw or a few very minor imperfections.
Front 60/40 or better · Back 90/10 or better
Near Mint
A clean-looking card with light flaws, such as slightly soft corners, minor edge wear, or small surface marks.
Front 65/35 or better
Excellent-Mint
A well-kept card with some visible corner, edge, or surface wear.
Front 70/30 or better
Excellent
A card with noticeable wear or printing flaws that still looks good overall.
Front 80/20 or better
Very Good–Excellent
A card with moderate wear and several visible flaws.
Front 85/15 or better
Very Good
A card with clear signs of handling, including rounded corners and noticeable surface or edge wear.
Front 85/15 or better
Good
A worn card with rounded corners, worn edges, and obvious surface flaws.
Front 90/10 or better
Fair
A heavily worn card with significant flaws in several areas.
Front 90/10 or better
Poor
A card with major damage, such as heavy creases, stains, severe wear, or damage to the card itself.
Authentic — No Number Grade
A card we believe is genuine, but which does not receive a condition grade. This may be due to damage, alterations, restoration, unusual manufacturing issues, or the submitter's request.